Preparing To Make A Nuisance Of Myself

by Joseph Dobrian on May 3rd, 2010
7 Comments

Pardon the past week’s absence of blog posts. I moved out of Manhattan last Monday, having lived there for 27 years, and relocated to Iowa City, Iowa. I’d like to plead the excuse that I’ve been too busy getting myself situated to do any blogging, but that would not be quite accurate. More to the point would be to say that for a week I’ve been using “getting myself situated” as an excuse not to do any blogging. I’m so avoidant, you see, that I even avoid social activities that I enjoy, such as casting my wisdom into Cyberspace.

Speaking of neurotic behavior, I’ve resolved not to surrender to the standard Iowa City uniform of a feed-cap, jeans or shorts, and a flapping t-shirt, or a sweatshirt when it’s cooler. I’m going to continue to wear my bespoke suits on weekdays, and a sport jacket on weekends, mostly because I like to, and partly because I’ve never been any good at blending in, wherever I am and whatever I’m doing – so if I can’t blend in, I might as well make the most of standing out.

It’s pretty clear that I’m going to stand out politically as well, at least in some circles – in a way that’s not likely to endear me to many. I’ve resolved to give up my long-standing habit of staying home and seldom partaking of social and cultural activities. I’ve been telling myself, for the past several months, that when I got to Iowa City I was going to make a special effort to get out there and go to lectures, concerts, recitals, gallery openings, and other such places where I could network, make business connections, and develop a social circle. So far, I’ve been doing a bit of that: going to suchlike events more days than not, anyway.

On this past Friday afternoon, I went to Dey House, a charming little library that houses the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, to hear a lecture by novelist Allan Gurganus. His topic was “Fiction As History, And Vice Versa.” Mr. Gurganus is a fine speaker, and his lecture was interesting to me until he started dropping gratuitous political comments such as “There is no such thing as a Republican artist, period. And if you mention Ayn Rand or Kevin Costner, the exits are there and there.” He also remarked how horrified and disgusted he was that the Supreme Court had ruled that “multinational corporations” could engage in political speech via financial contributions.

Naturally these sallies met with murmurs of approval from the audience. It’s funny and frustrating to me that in many academic or soi-disant intellectual circles, you can say “multinational corporations” and it’s as though you’ve said “child molestor.” People who belong to such circles, ironically, often have an aversion to critical thinking. Perhaps they believe an emotional reaction to a demagogic ploy is somehow more “genuine,” or perhaps they’re afraid that if they question the orthodox position, their peers won’t think they’re cool. I’m not sure.

At the end, when Mr. Gurganus called for questions, I promised myself I’d ask a question if someone else did first, but nobody did, so I didn’t. What I wanted to ask was this: “Regarding your assertion that there are no Republican artists, do you suggest that it’s the party registry that disqualifies a person from artistry? Or are there certain positions on certain issues that you may not hold if you’re an artist? I’m curious, Mr. Gurganus. Is there a calculus, by which one’s political opinions are weighed against the artistic merit of one’s œuvre? Or are you just a horse’s ass?”

Okay, I wouldn’t have said the last part, but I’m sure Mr. Gurganus would have heard it. But if I’d asked the preceding questions, I can promise you I’d not have been forgotten by anyone in that room. What scandal I’d have caused! What a name I’d have made for myself, instantly, as a horrible Grinch who dared to disrupt that wonderful lecture with his insulting and impertinent questions that presumed to contradict that which we all KNOW is the truth!

The following day, I attended another social event where I was introduced to a woman of about my own age who’d been at the lecture, and she asked me, “Wasn’t it wonderful?” I said, “I was enjoying it very much, until he started getting all arrogant and dismissive.” She was genuinely astonished, and asked me what I was referring to. I explained myself, but she still seemed a bit taken aback. I’m sure she was intelligent enough to grasp, intellectually, that some people could have been offended by Mr. Gurganus’ remarks – but the fact remains that I had to point out the offense. She would never have noticed it, herself.

There’s a smugness, I believe, in some Iowa City circles: a notion that of course all decent people think a certain way, and that other opinions merit not the slightest consideration, but merely a reflexive scorn. I’m just enough of a busybody, just enough of a sower of discord, that I intend to do something about it. Maybe that “something” will take away from my avoidance rituals. I can only hope so.

- Josephus Rex Imperator


Categories: Uncategorized

Comments

Trackback URL

  • Nina

    For a few years in the 1990s, i was an employee of Iowa State University in Ames. If i am not mistaken, ISU is the rival school to Univ. of Iowa, located in your new home, Iowa City.

    Now, my understanding is that the undergrad population at ISU, being largely from farming families, is overwhelmingly more conservative than the faculty. Doesn’t sound like that is the case at Univ. of Iowa.

    At the same time, I still could not really figure out Iowa politics: any state w/ Chuck Grassle as one senator and that looney leftie [whose name escapes me] as the other will forever confuse me.

    Perhaps you just encountered that smugness b/c Iowa City is a college town, and college towns are typically smug and clueless - e.g. Austin, Texas,, a blueberry in a sea of red.

    I was constantly reminded by my ISU friends and colleagues that “Iowa is different.” In fact, a close friend whom I still keep in touch with is a very moderate Dem who worked for Rep. Jim Leach and Gov. Vilsack - he would be as disgusted as you were by the responses you’ve described.

    Next time, be bold! Be the first to ask the question! You won’t be sorry you did! )

    Good luck in Iowa!

    Nina


  • Ho

    Welcome (back) to life in a college town.

    I do wish that you had asked your questions - they were along the lines of what I was wondering as I read what he said.

    But, be careful! You don’t want anyone accusing you of waving a chicken breast on a fork and terrorizing restaurant patrons!

    I am happy to hear how settled in you already seem to be.


  • AED

    Have you been eating breakfast at the HyVee deli? That’s the only place I see feed caps on a regular basis, and most of those guys don’t live inside city limits. Living on the northside and working downtown, most of the people I encounter are somewhat more stylish (especially the women), though generally only the lawyers wear suits and this are easily identified as such. Hawkeye caps downtown, if a cap is worn. I wear jeans with a stylish top for casual, never to work, and only wear t-shirts to exercise or work in the yard.


  • JRI

    This first week, and the couple of weekends I spent here previously, I’ve been spending a lot of time at Lowe’s and Menard’s and Kmart, so I guess I’ve been exposed mainly to a different demographic.


  • Gary

    Much as I’ve always admired Gurganus for “Last Confederate Widow”, etc. (can’t remember full title), as a mushy moderate I share your perceptions.

    I’ve said this before in other forums, but I’ll repeat it: the reason that lefties “reflexively” dismiss opposing viewpoints is not simply because they disagree with them; rather, they view the parties on the other side are not simply wrong or misguided — they’re Evil and Oppressive.

    Capitalism: Evil and Oppressive. Corporations: Evil and Oppressive. Republicans: Evil and Oppressive. Sarah Palin: Evil and Oppressive — well, you get the point.

    Similar thinking tends to prevail on the right. This demonizing of the opposition is very unhealthy for the body politic, in my opinion.

    I think you should speak up in these venues. Many people in Iowa City might benefit from having their rigid viewpoints challenged, as long as it’s done in a friendly, respectful manner (per the guidelines at the Dive Bar).


  • jb

    Smug is IC’s unspoken middle name - just count the Prius-es (Prii?) and think of the ratio, especially in a place with an average work commute of 4 miles.

    And yes the university towns are always much more left than the surrounding area or community. You should speak up next time. most of those kids don’t ask questions because they don’t want to look dumb or un-hip. but i think you may be surprised at how many libertarian thinkers are in their midst. i have several very conservative friends even though i am a left wing knee jerk Johnson County whacko liberal with a union card.

    i think there needs to be a lot more listening and a lot less demonizing. i learn tons and tons from my friends with different opinions to me. as long as no one gets snipingly personal i love a good exchange of ideas. i think a lot more people would too if they’f stop worrying about being “wrong” and just open up to another opinion.

  • Ayn Rand wasn’t an artist and Kevin Costner’s credentials are dubious. Gurganus dounds a lot like someone who’s confused about “art.” You should have asked your question (absent the “horse’s ass” bit until after he’d responded.) I think there’s fertile territory for interesting dialog in your reclaimed venue. Good luck there, btw.

Leave Comment

Commenting Options

Alternatively, you can create an avatar that will appear whenever you leave a comment on a Gravatar-enabled blog.